Storefront view of a hawker stall named "SEAFOOD SOUP" with an ordering counter on the left and a compact dining area with wooden tables on the right.

My sister doesn’t hand out favourites easily.

So when she told me Yanji Gourmet Seafood Soup was her favourite fish soup in Singapore, I listened. I love fish soup. I have spent years chasing a good bowl. If someone I trust says she has found one, I go.

She warned me about the queues. So we picked a weekday afternoon, the quiet hour when most places breathe out.

It didn’t matter. We walked into the Far East Plaza outlet and took the last two seats.

The waitress told us the food would take 30 to 40 minutes.

We waited.

What the Wall Told Me

Wall mural displaying brand information, awards, and seafood imagery for "YANJI SEAFOOD SOUP by GoodEarth" above dining tables.

There is not much to do during a 40-minute wait except read the walls.

The posters at Yanji Gourmet Seafood Soup By GoodEarth say the soup is made with chicken and pork bones. I took note. That one line explains most of what came next.

A fish soup built on chicken and pork bones is already telling you what it wants to be.

The Bowl

Light blue bowl filled with a creamy, yellow-toned seafood or fish soup containing sliced fish pieces and fresh tomato wedges

I ordered the fish soup without seafood. I wanted to taste the fish and the broth without distractions.

The fish was not the problem. There was a decent amount of it. The slices were properly portioned, with some minced pork mixed in. Nobody cut corners on the fish.

The problem was the soup.

It was very thick. Heavy on the spoon. It coated the fish and sat on the tongue. The more I ate, the more it felt like a thick soup that happened to have fish in it. The fish didn’t lead. The broth did.

It wasn’t a fish soup to me. It was a thick soup with fish slices in it.

There also wasn’t much of it. By the time I reached the bottom, I was looking for more broth. That would’ve helped dilute the heaviness. It wasn’t there.

What I Look For

Light blue bowl containing a rich yellow soup with minced meat, fish pieces, and a ceramic soup spoon.

I should be clear about where I’m coming from.

My idea of a good fish soup is simple. Sweet, natural, clear. The sweetness should come from the fish and the bones, not from anything added. You should see through it. There should be enough collagen to leave a light stickiness on your lips, a quiet sign the bones gave everything they had.

And it should never overpower. A good fish soup lets the fish speak. You finish the bowl and feel lighter, not heavier.

That is the bowl I measure every other bowl against.

For a different expression of fish soup, I think of places like Hup Lok, where the appeal lies in a more traditional fish soup experience. It is the kind of bowl I naturally gravitate towards, where the broth complements the fish rather than taking over.

Yanji’s soup goes in the opposite direction. It’s rich, dense and opaque. It’s built for weight and body, not clarity.

That’s not a mistake in the cooking. It’s a different idea of what the soup should be.

Credit Where It’s Due

Action shot of chefs working in a bustling commercial kitchen with steaming pots and prep stations.

This kind of broth doesn’t happen by accident.

You don’t get that thickness without hours at the stove. Bones boiled down, long and patiently, until the stock turns heavy. Someone in that kitchen is putting in the work. I respect that.

I also understand why so many people love it. Many Singaporeans like their soup thick and rich, the kind that feels substantial and comforting. The queue my sister warned me about is real for a reason. She is one of those people. She’s not wrong.

It simply isn’t my kind of bowl.

The Bill

Restaurant gourmet menu by Good Earth showcasing sections for Premium Soup, Seafood Soup, All-Fish Only, and Gourmet Porridge.

Two bowls. Over $30.

I thought that was excessive. Maybe not by Far East Plaza standards, or by the standards of anyone who loves this style. But for a bowl that left me wanting more soup and less weight, the number sat badly.

Price is personal, too. When a bowl moves you, you don’t count. When it doesn’t, you count every dollar.

I counted.

Would I Return

Interior view of a food stall workspace with staff working at the counters under pendant lights.

No.

Not at this price. Not even at $10 a bowl.

That sounds harsh, so let me be precise. If the price came down, the soup would still be thick. And the thickness is the thing I don’t want. Cheaper doesn’t change the bowl. It only changes what I pay for something I wouldn’t choose.

I don’t think Yanji Gourmet Seafood Soup is doing anything wrong. The fish was generous. The broth clearly takes time and effort. The crowd says plenty of people find exactly what they want here.

I’m just not one of them.

For anyone still exploring the city’s Chinese dining scene, there are plenty of other places worth considering. This guide to the best Chinese restaurants in Singapore is a good place to start, especially if you’re still figuring out which styles and places suit your taste.

We stepped back out into Far East Plaza afterward, and I thought about the clear bowls I’ve loved over the years. Light and sweet, gone before you notice. The kind that leaves you quiet.

This one left me full. That’s not the same thing.

If you like your fish soup thick and rich, go. You may find your favourite, like my sister did. If you like it clear, keep looking. I still am.


Leave a Reply

Trending